Rubric: Mina’s decision: interpretation rubric

Task: Compare two plausible explanations for Mina’s final action and defend the better-supported reading with text details. State what remains unknown.
Learning objective: Compare plausible interpretations, weigh relevant textual evidence, and explain what the passage leaves unresolved.

Constructed passage: Mina folded the letter, placed it beside the sealed envelope, and left the desk. At the doorway, she turned back and moved the lamp closer to the page.

"Criterion"	"Level 3"	"Level 2"	"Level 1"
"Source fidelity"	"Uses accurate, relevant details from the passage and distinguishes observation from inference."	"Uses a partly relevant detail, but misstates it or leaves observation and inference unclear."	"Uses no relevant detail or relies on information the passage does not provide."
"Interpretive reasoning"	"Compares two plausible explanations, weighs relevant details in each, and defends which reading is better supported while noting what remains unknown."	"Offers one plausibly supported explanation without comparing it with an alternative, or names two plausible explanations without weighing how well the evidence supports either."	"Makes a claim the passage does not support, misstates a detail, or treats an uncertain motive as established fact."
"Uncertainty and scope"	"Names what the passage leaves unresolved and keeps the conclusion within that limit."	"Notices an unresolved detail but does not explain how it limits the conclusion."	"Treats an uncertain motive as established fact or ignores a material limit."
