Download the response checklist

A plain-text worksheet for organizing the notice, deadline, course rules, existing writing records and questions for a student adviser. It is a preparation aid, not evidence or a prediction of the outcome.

Use a blank record for your own work. Keep examples separate from your evidence and follow the instructions below.

A marked-up draft with coral highlights, a cobalt note card, mint checklist and lavender pen.
A visual reminder to revise a marked passage while keeping its original context.
On this page

Separate a detector flag from a formal finding

Start by identifying what actually happened. A highlighted passage, a detector percentage, an instructor question and a formal allegation are different steps. Save the exact message, report and submission version you were shown. Note who sent it, what action they asked for and any response deadline.

If the report is from Turnitin, its current documentation says the AI-writing percentage is independent of the Similarity score. It describes a model estimate for qualifying text, not a probability that a student committed misconduct. Turnitin also says its model can misidentify human-written and AI-generated text and should not be used as the sole basis for adverse action. Read the explanation for the specific report version rather than interpreting a number on your own.

University procedures differ. For example, the University of Sydney describes written notice, response instructions and a timeframe in its investigation process; that is an example of one institution’s procedure, not a rule for every student. Your course instructions and institution’s current policy determine the steps that apply to you.

Supporting reading: [1] [3]

Preserve the writing records you already have

A preparation record can organize context without claiming that any single file proves authorship.
Record you already haveWhat it may help explainWhat it does not settle by itself
Drafts or document historyHow the document changed over timeWhy each change was made or whether the course rule was followed
Outline, notes and source locatorsHow the question, reading and argument connectWhether every claim is accurate or every source was used appropriately
Tool conversation or edit record, if one existsWhat operation you asked for and what output you reviewedWhether that operation was permitted for this assignment
Instructor comments or assignment instructionsThe task requirements and guidance you receivedThe outcome of an investigation under your institution’s procedure

Keep the submitted file and records from the process as they exist. Depending on how you worked, useful context may include earlier drafts, an outline, reading notes, source locators, comments, document version history, permitted tool conversations or instructor feedback. Do not delete or rewrite the original to make it look different, and do not invent a timeline or recreate notes as though they were written earlier.

A record can help explain one part of a process without proving everything about authorship. A document history may show when text changed; it does not, by itself, show why a revision was made. Reading notes can connect a claim to a source; they do not automatically settle whether a particular kind of assistance was allowed. Keep records secure and share only what is relevant through the official channel.

Supporting reading: [2]

Check the assignment rule and the response deadline

Read the assignment sheet, syllabus, course announcements and any AI-use guidance that applied when you completed the work. Policies can distinguish brainstorming, spelling support, translation, rewriting and generated prose. Record the specific instruction, not a general impression that AI was either allowed or prohibited.

If you received a formal notice, follow its directions and response deadline. Find the current institutional process and check what it says about the allegation, access to evidence, meetings, support people and appeal steps. If the notice does not explain what you need to answer, ask the named office or instructor for clarification in writing. Do not assume that a process described by another university applies to yours.

UC Davis advises students to follow the directions in a conduct notice and prepare to discuss their work and process. Its FAQ also says that students should defer to the course team’s policy for the specific assignment. These are useful reminders, but your own institution’s written process controls.

Supporting reading: [2] [3]

Prepare a concise, factual response

Make a short timeline from records you can verify: when you planned, read, drafted, received feedback and submitted the work. Mark what you know directly and what you cannot confirm. If you used an AI or editing tool, describe the tool and the task accurately, including any output you kept or changed. Do not minimize permitted use or claim that you never used a tool if that is untrue.

Connect each item you bring to a specific question. You might explain why a source supports a claim, how you chose a method or what a revision changed. If the instructor has identified passages, be ready to discuss those passages in context. The University of Sydney recommends that students facing an allegation seek support from independent student advocacy services before responding; UC Davis likewise describes reviewing the process and giving students an opportunity to respond. Availability and rules differ by institution.

You can ask for the specific report or passages being discussed, the policy being applied and the next procedural step. Keep your tone calm and direct. If you do not understand a question, ask for it to be clarified. Make a note of what you submit and when.

Supporting reading: [2] [3]

Avoid shortcuts that create new risks

Do not use a “humanizer,” rewrite the paper to change a detector result or submit the work to several free detector websites to find a more reassuring score. Those actions do not establish authorship or permission and can create new privacy, attribution or policy questions. The University of Sydney specifically cautions against third-party similarity and AI-detection sites because submitted work may be misused.

Be wary of outside services promising a guaranteed appeal result. The University of Sydney warns that external companies advertising help with academic cases may make misleading success claims or encourage unethical practices. Use the student advocacy, academic advising or support contacts listed by your own institution instead.

If you discover that some AI use may not have followed the instructions, do not hide it or alter the record. Explain the actual use and ask what the formal process requires. A truthful account gives the decision-maker relevant context; it does not guarantee a particular outcome.

Supporting reading: [3] [4]

Questions about this topic

Does an AI detector score prove that I used AI?

A score describes what a particular detection system estimated under its own method. Turnitin says its AI writing model can misidentify human-written and AI-generated text and should not be the sole basis for adverse action. Your institution’s process and all relevant evidence matter; the score alone is not a complete authorship record.

What should I do first if my instructor says my essay was flagged?

Save the notice and note any deadline. Keep the submitted file and existing drafts, notes, sources and version history unchanged. Read the assignment’s AI-use instructions and ask what specific passages, report or policy raised the concern.

Should I run my essay through another AI detector?

That cannot establish who wrote the essay or settle a course decision. A third-party checker may also require you to upload work; the University of Sydney advises students to avoid third-party similarity or AI-detection sites because of possible misuse of submitted work. Check privacy terms before sharing any text.

What if I used an AI tool for part of the assignment?

Describe what you actually used, for which task and how you handled its output. Check the course instructions that applied to this assignment. UC Davis advises students who have used AI to be prepared to explain or show how they used it and to answer questions about their work and process.

Can I appeal an academic-integrity finding?

Appeal rights, grounds, contacts and deadlines vary by institution. Read the decision notice and the current student conduct or academic-integrity procedure, then contact the listed student advocacy or support service promptly if you need help.

Sources and editorial notes

The supporting reading below informs our editorial guidance. Exercises and scenarios illustrate a method; they do not report a completed product test or measured learning outcome. Read our editorial policy or send a correction with a supporting source to info@ai-essay.com.

  1. Turnitin Guides: Using the AI Writing Report
  2. UC Davis Student Conduct and Integrity: Frequently Asked Questions
  3. University of Sydney: Detection and investigation of academic integrity breaches
  4. University of Oxford AI Competency Centre: The Question of AI Detection